Should I Hire a Property Manager for My Rental Property?
Owning a rental property can be a great source of passive income, but managing it? Not always so passive! From handling tenant issues to maintenance requests and rent collection, there’s a lot that goes into running a successful rental. If you’re asking yourself,
“Should I hire a property manager for my rental property?” you’re in the right place. In this blog, we’ll walk you through the benefits, drawbacks, and key factors to consider, helping you make an informed decision that works for you and your investment.
What Does a Property Manager Do?
A Property Manager’s Job: Beyond Collecting Rent
A lot of people think property management is just about collecting rent checks. Sure, that’s a part of it, but a property manager’s responsibilities go far beyond that. Here's what a professional property management company typically handles:
- Tenant Screening: From background checks to income verification, they help ensure your tenants are qualified, reducing the risk of late payments or evictions.
- Maintenance & Repairs: No more middle-of-the-night phone calls about a broken toilet! A property manager coordinates all maintenance, repairs, and routine inspections to keep your property in tip-top shape.
- Rent Collection: Property managers ensure rent is collected on time and follow up with tenants when payments are late.
- Handling Legalities: From lease agreements to local regulations, property managers make sure you're in compliance with all applicable laws, avoiding fines and legal trouble.
- Marketing & Vacancies: When tenants move out, a property manager takes charge of advertising, showing the property, and finding new tenants quickly.
- Evictions: While no one likes to talk about it, evictions are sometimes necessary. A property manager handles the legal process from start to finish, ensuring everything is done by the book.
So, while you might enjoy being a hands-on landlord, having a property manager can save you from a lot of headaches and time-consuming tasks.
The Benefits of Hiring a Property Manager
Letting Go: Why Delegating Could Be the Best Decision
When you're juggling multiple rental properties or simply don’t want to be glued to your phone 24/7, hiring a property manager could be the stress reliever you didn’t know you needed. Let’s dive into some of the biggest benefits of working with a property management company.
1. Save Time
One of the most significant advantages is time. Managing a rental property can be a full-time job—whether it’s responding to maintenance requests, screening potential tenants, or dealing with late payments. A property manager frees up your schedule, allowing you to focus on other ventures or simply enjoy more personal time.
2. Avoid Tenant Drama
Not every tenant experience will be a pleasant one. From disputes between tenants to late-night noise complaints, dealing with tenant issues can be emotionally exhausting. A property manager acts as the middleman, ensuring issues are resolved while keeping you at arm’s length from the drama.
3. Better Rent Collection
Late or missed rent payments can affect your cash flow. A professional property manager ensures rent is collected on time, handles follow-ups, and enforces lease terms, so you can rest easy knowing your rental income is reliable.
4. Fewer Vacancies
Experienced property managers know how to market your property effectively. From writing enticing rental ads to showcasing the property in its best light, they’ll get your units filled faster. Plus, they can set competitive rental rates that maximize your earnings while keeping the property occupied.
5. Legal Know-How
The laws surrounding rental properties can be complicated. From fair housing laws to security deposit regulations, staying compliant is crucial to avoid legal headaches. A property manager is well-versed in local regulations and ensures your property meets all legal requirements.
6. Reliable Maintenance
Routine maintenance and quick repairs are crucial to keeping your property in good condition and your tenants happy. Property management companies typically have a network of reliable contractors, ensuring repairs are done quickly and efficiently, often at a lower cost than you’d find on your own.
The Drawbacks of Hiring a Property Manager
Is There a Downside? The Other Side of the Coin
As great as hiring a property manager can be, it’s important to weigh the potential downsides. After all, no decision is without its challenges.

1. Cost
One of the main reasons property owners shy away from hiring a manager is the cost. Property managers typically charge a percentage of the rent (anywhere from 5-10%), which can add up over time. However, it’s crucial to balance this with the time, stress, and potential legal costs you might save by having a professional handle the day-to-day tasks.
2. Less Control
When you hand over the reins to a property manager, you’ll naturally have less control over the day-to-day decisions. While this is great for people looking to free up their time, it might not sit well with landlords who like to be more hands-on.
3. Potential for Mismatched Goals
A property manager’s goal is to keep your property filled and running smoothly, but their decisions may not always align perfectly with your goals as a landlord. For example, they might approve a tenant that you personally wouldn’t have chosen.
4. Trust Issues
Not all property managers are created equal, and handing over your investment to someone else requires trust. Doing your homework and thoroughly vetting potential management companies is crucial to ensure they’re a good fit for your property.
When Should You Hire a Property Manager?
Is It the Right Time? Key Considerations
Not every rental property owner needs a property manager. The decision often depends on your situation, and certain factors can help you determine whether now is the right time to hire one.
- You Own Multiple Properties: If you have more than one rental property, managing them all yourself can be overwhelming. A property manager can help ensure none of your investments fall through the cracks.
- You Don’t Live Nearby: If you don’t live close to your rental property, handling tenant issues, maintenance, and inspections can become challenging. A local property manager can take care of these tasks for you.
- You Have a Busy Schedule: If you have a full-time job or other commitments, managing a property might be too time-consuming. A property manager takes that burden off your plate.
- You Don’t Like the Day-to-Day Management: Some people are natural landlords, while others dread handling tenant requests or dealing with complaints. If managing the property is causing you stress, it might be time to hire a professional.
How to Choose the Right Property Manager
Finding the Right Fit for Your Property
If you’ve decided to hire a property manager, the next step is finding one that fits your needs. Here are a few tips to make sure you pick the right one:
- Check Their Experience: Look for a company that specializes in the type of property you own, whether it's residential, commercial, or vacation rentals.
- Ask for References: Speak to other landlords or property owners who have worked with the company to get an idea of their performance.
- Review the Contract Carefully: Before signing anything, review the property management agreement to understand their responsibilities, fees, and what happens if you’re unhappy with their services.
- Look at Their Track Record: Research the company’s history, including tenant retention rates and how they handle maintenance requests.
Call Our Team at Cairncross Property Management Today to Manage Your Rental Property in San Diego, CA!
If the idea of dealing with tenant complaints, late-night maintenance calls, or marketing your vacant property sounds like more work than you signed up for, it might be time to bring in the professionals. At Cairncross Property Management, we take the stress out of managing rental properties, so you can focus on what really matters.
Our experienced team offers a full range of property management services, from tenant screening and rent collection to handling repairs and legal compliance. Ready to let us manage the hard stuff?
Contact us at
(858) 490-1450 or
click here to fill out the form for expert property management services in
San Diego, CA, and the surrounding areas.
FAQs
What are typical property management fees?
Property management fees usually range between 5-10% of your monthly rental income, depending on the location, services, and company.
Can property managers help with legal issues?
Yes, property managers can assist with legal compliance, including lease agreements, fair housing laws, and eviction procedures.
How do property managers handle tenant screening?
Property managers conduct thorough tenant screenings, including credit checks, rental history, and income verification, to ensure reliable tenants.
Do property managers help with maintenance and repairs?
Yes, they coordinate all repairs and maintenance, often working with a network of contractors to ensure quick and cost-effective solutions.
Can a property manager help reduce tenant turnover?
Yes, by addressing tenant needs, handling maintenance promptly, and ensuring fair treatment, a property manager can help improve tenant satisfaction and reduce turnover.
Posted in Uncategorized
CAIRNCROSS PROPERTY MANAGEMENT
BRE# 001926213
TENANTS
QUICK LINKS
Cairncross Property Management is committed to ensuring compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, including incorporating the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 (https://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG21/) and applying Level A Success Criteria and Conformance Requirements. Any concerns regarding accessibility can be directed to
support@doorgrow.com. Please find our
Website Accessibility Policy here. Aug 4, 2020